Jonah Naplan November 20, 2026
“The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping” is a fascinating, frustrating movie with so many talented people involved that you’ll wonder what went wrong. Had it been completely awful, that may have been better, being that general audiences tend to remember dumpster fires more than they do movies that just fall short of greatness or total ruin. That’s where this new entry in a beloved YA franchise, originally written by Suzanne Collins, more or less lies. Based on the bestselling novel that released only last year, you get the sense early on that maybe some things are best left on the page, as the film struggles with how to make the origin story of Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zada)—who grows up to be Katniss and Peeta’s District 12 mentor, and also to be played by Woody Harrelson—interesting enough to keep an over two-and-a-half-hour movie afloat.
Long story short, it sinks. Not just because of the movie’s ambitious size, but because most of the components that should make it great, well, don’t quite get there. Directed by Francis Lawrence, who helmed all but the first “Hunger Games” movie and has inexplicably become the Kevin Feige of this franchise, and written by Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie, “Sunrise on the Reaping” never exactly justifies its existence. The occasional moments of inspiration are there but ultimately fail to elevate a story formula that we’ve seen done much better in several previous iterations of this world to anything memorable.
At times a lofty bildungsroman, the origins of Haymitch Abernathy appear all-too-familiar. The product of a poor District 12 family, he’s summoned to compete in the 50th Annual Hunger Games, aka the Second Quarter Quell, on his birthday, leaving behind a loving family and his girlfriend Lenore (Whitney Peak). In this year’s games, four tributes are selected from each district, making for 48 kids in total, fighting to the death in the arena. Alongside Haymitch, the other boy tribute is Wyatt Callow (Ben Wang, who was also featured in Lawrence’s excellent “The Long Walk”), while the girls turn out to be Maysilee Donner (McKenna Grace, adding another major franchise to her impressive resume), and little Louella McCoy (Molly McCann), who Haymitch begins caring to like a younger sister. One of the movie’s biggest faults is that it never defines any of these other tributes beyond basic archetypes before they step into the ring—Wyatt is booksmart, Maysilee is pampered and sultry, Louella is small but mighty, and that’s it.
Like 2023’s “Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes,” this one is also divided into three acts or chapters, but different from its superior predecessor, they’re hardly distinct nor do they outline specific beats whatsoever. The first hour is probably the messiest as Haymitch trains, meets other competitors, and forms possible alliances. Unlike other movies in this series, tributes from other districts get even less developed, and it’s not because there’s double the usual amount; on the contrary, for as much time as the movie spends setting up for the actual tournament, it has entirely different things on its mind, such as accelerating the fan service by introducing younger versions of infamous Panem characters, like President Snow (a smarmy Ralph Fiennes, forever haunted by the memory of Lucy Gray), then-Capitol-agent Plutarch Heavensbee (Jesse Plemons, taking over from the late, great Philip Seymour Hoffman), the rambunctious Effie Trinket (Elle Fanning), and master of ceremonies Caesar Flickerman (the antics of Kieran Culkin). It’s to be expected by this point in a “Hunger Games” movie that the dedicated ensemble of classy actors will do most of the heavy worldbuilding, and the same is once again true here.
The work of such greats like Fiennes and Plemons turns increasingly vital once it becomes clear that silver screen newbie Zada can’t quite hold his own as the narrative leans heavier, and at times it sounds like he’s merely doing an impression of Harrelson’s rendition of the character, and not a very good one. Despite everybody else, “Sunrise on the Reaping” is solely a movie about Haymitch, and he gets just as much screentime as Katniss did in the original movies. Unlike Jennifer Lawrence’s now-iconic performance as the fiery rebel-that-could, though, Zada never manages to balance the part of a young man whose traumas both before and after the Games alienated him from society and inclined him towards the bottle, but who appears darkly charming on the outside as a way of masking his hopelessness. As somebody who’s only read the first book in this series, once for pleasure and once to dissect its blunt iconoclasm in school, it may be more a criticism of Collins’ 2025 novel to say that I didn’t believe for a second that any of this had always happened to Harrelson’s character before he met Katniss, and felt that this rebellious backstory was only surmised post-“Mockingjay” as a way to parallel her revolutionary exploits. You can feel the blatant similarities to that original 2012 movie throughout, while director Lawrence adds nothing new to the formula.
On a visual level, “Sunrise on the Reaping” is a film of immaculate composition. If the Capitol embodied a gray sort of dystopia by the time Katniss entered the 74th Hunger Games, then this movie posits that Haymitch was reaped around the “Golden Ages” of Panem, a time when color and culture ran wild (costumes designed by Bina Daigeler), and conformity hadn’t yet reached its insurmountable peak. The arena itself is a stunning preserve of green forest and white mountains, a stunning backdrop to such heinous action and agonizing sacrifice. Shot by cinematographer Jo Willems (marking his fifth “Hunger Games” movie), the way this film juxtaposes the pastoral beauty of the terrain with the violence that ensues within, all while highlighting the ways that the Capitol can control the atmospheric conditions and summon a natural disaster at the snap of a finger, is haunting. And yet, the movie takes so long to actually get to the arena that by the time we finally arrive, the sequence can’t help but feel somewhat rushed through in order to reach the story’s tragic conclusions.
It wouldn’t be a spoiler to disclose how it all ends up, but “Sunrise on the Reaping” instead shoehorns in its own wish-fulfilling final note which is all at once cheap and unnecessary, as if the filmmakers didn’t trust that the story’s own terms were enough to end on. I was left wondering by the end of its 158 minutes if the narrative was anywhere near compelling or original enough to warrant such an epic runtime, and ultimately I decided it wasn’t. The movie is all professionally assembled and produced and looks expensive, but the central storyline makes you want to revisit its superior predecessors rather than dive into its own intricacies because we’ve seen it all before.
As a companion piece to the first “Hunger Games”—and also somewhat to “Catching Fire”—“Sunrise on the Reaping” adds worthwhile detail to the allegorical stories audiences grew up haunted by, despite never finding a relevant annotation on why Haymitch might have been particularly allured by the will of his personal trainees 24 years later. Rather, it sloppily conveys that a man so pained by a sinister system retreated to anonymity for years as a way of reconciling his traumas and broken desires, with Zada ultimately acting not as a profound avatar of who Haymitch was before he entered the trenches, but a manifestation of the ways in which totalitarian cruelty hardens promising young men, and a money-hungry film industry makes real inspiration moot. He’s earned the right to drink.
Now playing in theaters.
